Skip to content

WooCommerce Subscriptions vs MemberSutra: Do You Need Both?

In this article

WooCommerce Subscriptions is the official way to bill customers on repeat in WooCommerce. MemberSutra also bills on repeat, but it is a membership plugin first. So store owners often ask us: if I use MemberSutra, do I still need WooCommerce Subscriptions? And if I already have WooCommerce Subscriptions, why would I add MemberSutra?

This WooCommerce Subscriptions vs MemberSutra comparison answers both questions: what each plugin does, where they overlap, what they cost, and when it makes sense to use one, the other, or both together.

Disclosure: we make MemberSutra. WooCommerce Subscriptions details come from its official WooCommerce.com page (checked October 2026). It is a mature, capable extension, and we say where it is the better choice.

Key takeaways

WooCommerce Subscriptions handles recurring billing only; it does not restrict content or run a member area.

MemberSutra has its own subscription engine plus memberships, so many stores need only MemberSutra.

If you already use WooCommerce Subscriptions, MemberSutra works alongside it: memberships follow those subscriptions.

WooCommerce Subscriptions supports more gateway extensions; MemberSutra has free Stripe, PayPal and Razorpay gateways with gateway-run billing.

Do You Need Both?

Usually not. If you are starting fresh and want subscriptions plus members-only content, MemberSutra covers both. If you only sell recurring physical products and need a gateway that only WooCommerce Subscriptions supports, it alone is enough. You need both only when you already run WooCommerce Subscriptions and want to add memberships without moving your existing subscribers to a new billing engine.

Decision guide: WooCommerce Subscriptions, MemberSutra or both

What Each Plugin Does

WooCommerce Subscriptions adds subscription products to WooCommerce: weekly, monthly or annual billing, free trials, signup fees, synchronised billing dates, upgrades and downgrades with proration, gift subscriptions, manual renewals with any gateway and automatic renewals with more than 25 gateways. Customers can switch plans, update details and suspend or cancel from My Account. It costs $279 a year with a 30-day money-back guarantee, and it is rated 3.9 out of 5 from 142 reviews on WooCommerce.com at the time of writing.

MemberSutra is a membership plugin with subscriptions built in. Alongside recurring billing it handles membership plans, content restriction, the member area, member discounts, gifts, subscription boxes, drip content and analytics. The free version bills on daily and weekly cycles; Pro ($99 a year for one site) adds monthly and yearly billing, trials and signup fees.

WooCommerce Subscriptions vs MemberSutra comparison table

Pricing

For subscriptions alone, WooCommerce Subscriptions is $279 a year. If you also want to lock content for subscribers, the official route adds WooCommerce Memberships at $199 a year, $478 in total. MemberSutra Pro is $99 a year for both jobs, or free if day and week billing cycles are enough.

Billing Features Compared

On pure billing, both cover the essentials: trials, signup fees, synchronised renewal dates, plan switching with proration, gift subscriptions and customer self-service. A few differences worth knowing:

Gateway coverage: WooCommerce Subscriptions works with 25+ gateway extensions for automatic renewals. MemberSutra works with its free Stripe, PayPal and Razorpay gateways for automatic renewals, and any WooCommerce gateway for manual renewals.

Who charges renewals: with the MemberSutra gateways, a subscription can be created in Stripe Billing, PayPal Subscriptions or Razorpay Subscriptions so the gateway charges each renewal and keeps billing even if your site is down. You can also have your site charge renewals instead.

Renewal pricing: MemberSutra Pro can make renewals cheaper over time, for example 10% off from the fourth renewal.

Subscription boxes: MemberSutra Pro has a box product type where customers pick their items; WooCommerce Subscriptions needs other extensions for this.

Maturity: WooCommerce Subscriptions has been the standard for years and is widely supported by other extensions and developers.

Subscription settings on a WooCommerce product: billing cycle, signup fee and free trial
Subscription settings on a product in MemberSutra

Membership Features: The Big Difference

WooCommerce Subscriptions does not restrict content. If a subscriber should unlock pages, posts, downloads or members-only products, you need a membership plugin on top. MemberSutra includes plans, restriction rules, the Access Rules table, the member area in My Account and, with Pro, drip content, paywalls, member discounts and protected downloads.

Access rules table showing who can open each post, page and product
The MemberSutra Access Rules table

Using WooCommerce Subscriptions and MemberSutra Together

If you already have subscribers in WooCommerce Subscriptions, you do not have to move them. MemberSutra recognises WooCommerce Subscriptions: a MemberSutra membership linked to a WooCommerce Subscriptions product starts, renews, pauses and ends together with that subscription.

Keep the product’s subscription settings in WooCommerce Subscriptions.

Link the product to a MemberSutra plan as usual and choose what it unlocks.

Manage billing in WooCommerce → Subscriptions; membership access follows automatically.

Use one engine per product: do not make the same product a subscription in both plugins.

This is a gentle way to add memberships to an existing subscription store, and you can move new products to MemberSutra’s own subscriptions later if you want to.

Which Should You Choose?

Your situationRecommendation
New store, want subscriptions and members-only contentMemberSutra
Want to start free with weekly billingMemberSutra (free)
Sell subscription boxes or need Razorpay in IndiaMemberSutra Pro
Only sell recurring products and need a gateway outside Stripe, PayPal, RazorpayWooCommerce Subscriptions
Already on WooCommerce Subscriptions, want to add membershipsBoth: keep billing, add MemberSutra for access

Want the full picture on subscriptions? Read how to sell subscriptions in WooCommerce, or compare memberships plugins in MemberSutra vs WooCommerce Memberships.

FAQ: WooCommerce Subscriptions vs MemberSutra

No. MemberSutra has its own subscription engine for recurring billing. If you already use WooCommerce Subscriptions, MemberSutra works alongside it and its memberships follow those subscriptions.
For many stores, yes. MemberSutra bills subscriptions through free Stripe, PayPal and Razorpay gateways and adds memberships on top. WooCommerce Subscriptions supports more gateway extensions and has a longer track record.
No. WooCommerce Subscriptions handles billing only. To lock content for subscribers you need a membership plugin such as WooCommerce Memberships or MemberSutra.
WooCommerce Subscriptions costs $279 a year for one site, with a 30-day money-back guarantee, according to its WooCommerce.com page in October 2026.
No. Use one subscription engine per product. Keep a product’s subscription settings in WooCommerce Subscriptions and link it to a MemberSutra plan for access, or use MemberSutra’s own subscription settings, not both.
Yes, in Pro. MemberSutra Pro supports free and paid trials, signup fees, and plan switching from My Account with optional proration.

The Bottom Line

WooCommerce Subscriptions is excellent at one job: recurring billing. MemberSutra does recurring billing and memberships in one plugin, at a lower price, with a free version. If you are starting out, MemberSutra alone is usually enough. If you already run WooCommerce Subscriptions, keep it and add MemberSutra for members-only content, with no migration needed.

Start Selling Memberships on WooCommerce, Free
Membership plans, content restriction and recurring Stripe, PayPal & Razorpay payments in one plugin. The free plugin stays free.
Enter the URL of your WordPress website to get started
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy.
MemberSutra plan builder illustration with a subscription plan

Share this article

Leave a comment

On this page

Ready to sell memberships from your WooCommerce store?

Start free with MemberSutra, then upgrade to Pro when you need drip content, paywalls, gifts and analytics.